After some resolution tests i’ve been doing for another project, I’ve come to realise the importance of resolution for sterescopic work. I hadn’t realised before just how much stereoscopic information was lost between the pixels. There’s a number of ways to increase the sense of depth in any given shot, but a basic one is to simply increase the resolution. That is, if you have a display that is capable of displaying the additional resolution.
I *was* working to 720p due to the render times per frame and the maps not quite holding up at 1080p. After doing some thinking and having a cup of tea I came to the conclusion that most people who will see this film will be watching it online, or on a TV, and most of those people who have a stereoscopic display will have a full HD display, as the two usually come hand-in-hand. So, if you’re going to do a thing, it’s worth doing that thing properly and thus began the conversion of the project in HD.
This isn’t as simple as it sounds. First of all I had to re-render the final beauty pass, pretty simple, just some increased values to compensate, shadow samples etc. Then rerender an uber low res RPF pass for the new camera positional data… In After Effects, the RPF camera import data changes with the resolution, even if you’re not changing the camera position. Then every comp, solid and adjustment layer needs to be replaced with a higher resolution version. Any pixel based effect needs to be multiplied… blurs, mask feathers etc. All the particle comps need to be converted to a higher resolution to hold up. Every 3D layer needs rescaling to match. The new RPF data needs importing as well as any positional data exported from 3dsMax.
It’s not the quickest change to make, but the outcome is revealing, especially when looking at the stereoscopic depth. It’s interesting how much extra information is percieved in depth just by increasing the crispness of an edge. Therefore it’s worth pointing out that the anti-aliasing settings also have an impact on the stereoscopic outcome.
Below is an animated gif showing the difference between the two resolutions, when overlayed on top of each other. It’s not a perfect example as there are subtle changes in random particle positions due to the change of resolution in the comp as well as a slight change in convergence and lower anti-aliasing settings. Nevertheless, it is still possible to see more levels of depth throughout the image. Just seeing one or two extra pixels of accuracy in the parrallax is enough to place an object slightly infront of or behind another.
This amount of subtlty seems pretty much lost when considering the pace of movement in these shots, you don’t get any oportunities in the film to browse the depth at your leisure, but it definately increases the feeling of space when comparing the alternative resolutions as video. As your eye is thrown around the frame in sharp jolts, the brain still manages to build complex pockets of depth around the focus area. This is my experience anyway.
Another resolution comparison:
A selection of anaglyph stills at 1920×1080 resolution (Click to see full size):





Leave a comment