Lighting in S3D

Stereogram wigglegram animated 3d gif of cameras

The cinematic language is vast… With over a hundred years of development it has been refined to the point where most most people understand it as part of their native tongue. It can be hard to break the ‘rules’ of the language or come up with new words. Occasionally some experimental ideas begin to surface and gradually become part of the vocabulary. The world of cinema is undergoing a paradigm shift at the moment as stereoscopic films saturate the box office due to probably a very complex set of reasons. Some people hate 3D movies and some people love them, very few people have no opinion on them. I have mixed feelings about the current situation. I am deeply fascinated by stereoscopy as a creative tool and feel it can be a very powerful and emotive when used properly. The problem with 3D in the box office is that every film that is made has to be suitable for 2D and 3D. This limits what is achievable creatively for the stereoscopic version. There is also a feeling that some studios are producing 3D films as an after thought to take advantage of the higher ticket prices, but the films being produced have little thought about the stereoscopic depth. This has no real benefit to the experience and doesn’t really help develop the stereoscopic language.

I am currently exploring some ideas about lighting in 3D and how it differs from a 2D production. Primarily I’m experimenting with a stereo camera but these ideas are developing in CG as well. I’ve stumbled upon a few things already. I’m starting to see just how much of current lighting technique is geared towards achieving depth. A rim or kick light might normally be used to separate a subject from the background, the same principle exists in s3d, but it can be treated differently. A 3D image doesn’t necessarily require a large amount of contrast between objects to separate them, as long as the depth is sufficient. It’s not like everyone has just been waiting to not have to use rim lights and this will shave a huge creative impact upon composing an image, but it is a factor that changes the way we think about things. The contrast across the whole image can be less and the stereoscopic depth can compensate in order for our brains to make sense of a scene. Perhaps this will give rise to some interesting subtly tonal shots that are only really understood through stereoscopic depth, almost like a magic-eye. I’m finding it helps to overlight things to achieve a richer sensation of depth, this could be related to iris expansion and focal accommodation. Too much contrast can be a little troublesome due to cross-talk or ghosting with some viewing technologies such as Infitec, but hopefully these things will one day be overcome. It feels more natural to lean towards more fill lighting at the moment. Subtle tonal variation seems to feel richer in 3D than it would normally in 2D. Subtly patterned surfaces can become an adventure in depth.

Another interesting shift is colour… I’ve not really done enough experimenting with colour yet to have built any conclusions but I do constantly refer to colour as an analogue to depth. The principles of colour as a cinematic device seem to translate to colour easily. Colour to focus attention. Depth can draw attention just as colour can. Distorting depth could have a very profound effect on how we perceive characters, the difference between soft and spiky perhaps, the difference between hero and villain.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.